Calm Leadership: Clarity Over Speed

Does the faster decision-maker make the better leader? Ask that question to a retail chain general manager in February 2023 — when inflation in Turkey was at record highs, election uncertainty had frozen most corporate planning cycles, and ChatGPT had just been declared a game-changer barely weeks earlier — and you would almost certainly hear ‘yes.’ Speed felt like the most reliable leadership virtue in that climate. I argue the opposite: in 2023, the most critical leadership deficit was not speed. It was clarity. And clarity comes from calmness — not from suppressing panic, but from being willing to stand behind a decision once it is made.This thesis is uncomfortable because dismissing calmness as a ‘soft skill’ is easy. Most leadership literature still treats calmness as a personality trait — either you have it or you do not. But field experience tells a different story: calmness is not a character feature, it is a decision methodology. And without that methodology, the speed organisations prize so highly tends to come back as a boomerang.Consider a 312-person mid-size retail chain headquartered in Ankara. In early 2023, they were managing three simultaneous pressures: suppliers revising prices roughly every 14 days, store managers forwarding competitor campaign alerts to the general manager in real time via WhatsApp, and a board pushing to accelerate digital transformation. In that environment, the general manager faced a different ‘urgent decision’ almost every week. In the vast majority of those decisions, what was missing was not speed — it was clarity: ‘Why are we making this call?’ went unanswered, ‘How will we measure success?’ was never asked, and ‘What would make us reverse course?’ was not on the table at all. Looking back six weeks later, 57 percent of fast-track decisions — drawn not from a survey but from the firm’s own internal decision log — had been revisited or effectively reversed. Speed created the illusion of momentum. It did not produce real progress.So what does the ‘clear leader’ do differently? Here we reach the most demanding part of the argument. The clear leader does not gather more data — that is a very common misconception. The clear leader asks fewer but better questions before committing. Three categories are worth separating in any significant decision: ‘I know this,’ ‘I am assuming this,’ and ‘This will remain uncertain.’ The second category is the most dangerous. Most fast decisions treat assumptions as facts. The calm leader names the assumption out loud — ‘I am deciding on the basis of this assumption; if I am wrong, here is what we will do.’ That single sentence simultaneously informs the organisation and lowers the cost of admitting error. The team already knows the leader is not infallible — but they are more willing to follow a leader who owns the assumption.The year 2023 carries a specific additional layer of difficulty. The wave from ChatGPT’s December 2022 launch had, by February 2023, found its way into internal management meetings across sectors. ‘Can we just ask the AI?’ became one of the first questions early adopters were raising in boardrooms. That question itself is not the problem — it is legitimate and often productive. The problem surfaces when the confident-looking but groundless outputs that large language models can generate (the hallucination issue is real and documented) meets a culture of hasty decisions. The leader suddenly has something that feels like a solid rationale in hand. The clear leader asks the same question here too: ‘What is the source of this output? Can it be verified?’ From a KVKK perspective, that question carries additional weight specific to Turkey: as of early 2023, data-processing terms of major model providers had not been clarified in local regulatory context, and the extent to which corporate data fed into these models remained private was genuinely uncertain. The calm leader is the one who can set that uncertainty on the table and say, plainly, ‘We do not yet know this.’How do organisations build this clarity systematically? Three concrete practices emerge consistently from field observation. The first is the ‘decision question’ discipline: before every significant decision meeting begins, the decision question is written in one sentence — ‘The question we must answer today is this.’ This focuses the meeting rather than constraining it. A food manufacturer in Izmir adopted this practice over an eight-month period and brought average meeting duration down from 73 minutes to 41 minutes — a figure taken from the finance director’s personal log, not a company survey. The second is the ‘assumption list’: the assumptions underlying a decision are recorded in the meeting note, along with a defined trigger for reversal. The third is the ‘first 14 days’ review: every strategic decision is subject to a brief ‘is this still correct?’ check two weeks later — not to undo the decision, but to calibrate its implementation.One genuine counterargument deserves its space here. These three practices do not eliminate the need to decide under real pressure. I am aware that in an acute crisis, there is no time to write a decision question before acting. Advocating for calmness is not the same as papering over the reality of leadership. What I am defending is narrower: the vast majority of non-emergency decisions are made under artificial speed pressure, and that pressure usually originates not outside but in the leader’s own discomfort with uncertainty. ‘Leaving without a decision feels like weakness’ — a general manager said exactly that to me once, and in doing so named the real problem. The clear leader recognises that feeling and does not surrender to it.Back to the opening question: speed or clarity? Could the Ankara retail chain’s general manager have given a different answer by August 2023 — six months in? I believe so. Because under sustained inflation pressure, the most expensive decision is the one you reverse. Winning is not about deciding fastest; it is about reversing least. Teams feel this, customers feel this, and the whole organisation senses it over time. Calmness is not a romantic ideal — it is a measurable leadership preference that minimises the cost of course correction. The real question worth sitting with: which of your decisions last quarter were driven by speed pressure you manufactured yourself?

This article was originally published in Turkish by Gökhan MERCANOĞLU on February 4, 2023. The English edition has been reviewed and edited by the author.


data warehouse creates lasting value only when user behavior, executive ownership, and data quality are handled together. Technology does not create transformation by itself; it only makes the need for transformation more visible. Success is less about the system working and more about the organization learning to work with it.


Gökhan Mercanoğlu
İş Zekâsı ve Raporlama