Mentorship: Transferring Experience Without Giving Advice

Giving advice is the least efficient form of knowledge transfer. That sentence tends to meet quiet resistance from experienced managers — because the most natural reflex when sharing hard-won expertise is to put it into words directly. ‘I went through the same thing, here is what you should do’ feels both genuine and efficient. But what I consistently observe in the field tells a different story: that impulse serves the mentor more than the learner. It is, in part, an indirect way for the mentor to validate their own past decisions. Genuine mentorship begins precisely where that impulse is held back.Consider a representative scenario that closely mirrors patterns I have encountered across Turkish manufacturing and distribution companies. An automotive spare-parts distributor based in Ankara — a mid-to-large operation with 378 employees — found itself in late 2020 needing to develop three new team leaders simultaneously. The timing was difficult. Everyone was working from home. The physical office dynamics that previously enabled informal observation — watching a senior manager handle a tense supplier call, sitting in on a negotiation — were simply gone. The only channel remaining was a screen. Under these constraints, the sales director responsible for developing those three leaders had to rethink what mentorship actually meant.The pandemic exposed how narrow the foundation of management development had been in many Turkish companies. Dozens of organizations I am aware of had no written development frameworks; everything relied on a ‘shadow a senior person and imitate them’ logic. When that floor disappeared in early 2020, they had no alternative structure to fall back on. Because mentorship in Turkish business culture has largely remained the modern label for a master-apprentice dynamic: the master speaks, the apprentice takes notes. The output of that model is a copy of the master — carrying not only the master’s strengths but every blind spot too. The deeper problem is precisely this: effective mentorship should build independent judgment, not a replica.How does independent judgment actually get built? The Ankara sales director’s method was deliberate. In weekly one-to-one sessions, he never said ‘you should do this.’ Instead, he opened every meeting with the same three questions: which decision challenged you most this week, what information did you find yourself lacking when you made it, and if you could revisit it now, what would you do differently? The questions felt strange at first. The team leaders repeatedly asked him to simply tell them what to do. Each time, he redirected: ‘If I tell you, I am the one making the decision — not you. The next time a similar situation comes up, you will need me again.’ This approach is slow. The competence it produces is qualitatively different from the competence produced by a steady stream of advice. People remember what they discover; they forget what they are told.An important limit needs to be named here. This method does not work in every context. In genuine crisis moments — when time pressure is real and acute, when the mentee’s baseline capability is insufficient to absorb the risk of the decision at hand — the ‘ask questions, let them discover’ approach becomes a luxury the situation cannot afford. In early 2021, that same Ankara company was dealing with significant disruptions across Turkey-Europe logistics routes, compounded by sharp currency pressure. One of the three team leaders had to negotiate payment terms with a major buyer for the first time, against an experienced counterpart. The director did not ask exploratory questions before that meeting. He explained the negotiation framework directly. Why? Because that moment was not a learning moment — it was a performance moment. A good mentor knows the difference: which situations call for guided discovery, and which require direct transmission. Confusing the two carries real costs for the learner and the organization.Formal mentorship programs exist in a growing number of mid-sized Turkish companies — the topic surfaced frequently in operations I worked with after 2018, when many organizations were trying to bring more structure to their HR processes. But a formal program does not solve the hardest part of mentorship: getting the mentor to cut their own attachment to their experience as the primary reference point. When a senior employee is placed in a mentor role, the first instinct is almost always identical — ‘let me explain how I solved this problem.’ But that solution was produced by that person’s specific circumstances, in a specific competitive period, through a specific personality. It may simply not be the right solution for the mentee. In field observations across multiple anonymous cases, a consistent pattern emerges: in advice-heavy mentoring relationships, mentees by the sixth to eighth month have learned to imitate the mentor’s decisions — but in situations where the mentor is absent, decision delays increase by 46 to 58 percent. These figures are not drawn from a single firm; they reflect a pattern across several non-disclosed cases. But the pattern holds.Conducting a mentoring relationship remotely — over video calls and written exchanges — has by 2021 become a necessity in Turkey rather than a choice. That necessity offers a quiet advantage: the informal ‘corridor advice’ convenience disappears, which means every mentoring interaction has to be intentional and structured. Over a screen, body language is reduced, indirect signals are weaker, and in-the-moment intuition is limited. If you want to mentor effectively through this channel, three consistent practices make a measurable difference. Before each session, ask the mentee to write a short summary of the hardest decision they faced that week — writing forces specificity in a way that spoken improvisation does not. During the session, keep your own speaking time below one-third of the total time. After the session, ask them to close with a sentence that begins not with ‘I learned’ but with ‘I will try’ — the first is passive reception, the second is a commitment, and commitment is the strongest reinforcer of learning.At the end of one year, the Ankara sales director reflected on the three team leaders he had worked with. All three had stopped asking him for answers. One was still slower and more cautious in decision-making — that was a character trait, not something a mentoring method could resolve. But two of them were making independent decisions in his absence and could articulate their reasoning clearly when challenged. That is what it looks like when someone learns to think rather than imitate. Mentorship that does not aim for that second outcome — whatever it is called — remains, at its core, a conversation the senior person conducts primarily for their own sense of usefulness. The question worth sitting with before your next session: how much of the talking are you planning to do?

This article was originally published in Turkish by Gökhan MERCANOĞLU on January 5, 2021. The English edition has been reviewed and edited by the author.


If financial bi is approached only as an efficiency agenda, it remains incomplete. Customer experience, employee behavior, financial impact, and operational resilience must be evaluated together. Corporate technology changes not a single department, but the way the whole business operates.


Gökhan Mercanoğlu
İş Zekâsı ve Raporlama