Writing a Digital Strategy: From Bright Ideas to Actionable Plans

Picture a mid-sized tourism chain operating three hotels in Antalya, employing 312 people across its properties. After closing the 2014 season, the general manager calls the agency in for a meeting and sets a 47-page digital strategy document on the table. It contains audience analyses, competitor positioning matrices, content pillars and an annual publishing calendar. The agency team nods. By late February the social media accounts are still empty, a brief is still awaited, and the season opens in six weeks. The document solved nothing — because the strategy ended before it could connect to execution.Two opposing camps dominate the digital strategy debate. The first insists that a comprehensive document must guide everything; the second argues ‘publish first, optimize later.’ Both are partly right — and both are insufficient on their own. Without a reference document the team questions the purpose of every post; without a shared document the agency reinvents the brand voice in every campaign. But when producing the document becomes the goal in itself, the actual work — content creation, the approval cycle, performance measurement — is pushed into second place. In Turkish tourism, retail and food KOBIs, this second trap is far more common than the first.What does an actionable digital strategy actually look like? It has two layers. The first covers brand identity and communication principles — this part changes slowly and is reviewed roughly every six months. The second covers the operational working arrangement — this part lives week to week. The first layer defines brand voice, key messages, visual framework and the purpose of each channel. The second layer consists of concrete operational decisions: the weekly brief format, approval workflow, who is responsible for content production, publishing schedule and performance indicators. In my field experience, the majority of agency-brand relationships in Turkey have the first layer reasonably well defined and the second layer almost entirely undefined. That gap means starting from scratch with every single content request.The weekly brief deserves a closer look. In a representative scenario from a mid-sized retail textile chain operating in the Aegean region, the brand manager sent the agency a message every Monday asking ‘what should we post this week?’ The agency proposed something, the brand rejected it, revisions went back and forth, the content was finally approved on Thursday and published on Friday. Three quarters of the week’s intended content was either delayed or never published at all. The problem was not the agency’s creative capability. The problem was that brand voice, tone, visual constraints and content priorities had never been defined in a written document. The agency was guessing every single time. This dynamic determines outcomes before any measurement conversation even begins: collecting performance data without systematic content production is meaningless.Measurement remains an unresolved issue for most Turkish brands in 2015. When the conversation cannot move beyond follower counts, likes and shares, digital strategy collapses into managing feelings. To understand what social media actually contributes to a brand, at least three questions need to be asked regularly: ‘Did this content reach a potential buyer, an existing customer or only current followers?’ — that is, reach quality; ‘Where does this touchpoint sit within the purchase journey?’ — that is, its position in the conversion path; and ‘Do we have a baseline measurement of brand perception?’ — that is, a reference point. Returning to the Antalya case: the hotel’s Instagram account had reached tens of thousands of followers by 2014, but the team had never tracked which channel was driving traffic to the reservation form. Money spent, no decision made — because the content machine started before the measurement system was built.There is a legitimate concern here, and it deserves an honest answer: trying to measure everything can also paralyse a strategy. For small teams, time spent on data analysis competes directly with time spent on content production. Telling a hotel’s two-person digital team to ‘build the analytics infrastructure first’ without considering sector, scale and team structure is imposing an enterprise process on an organisation that is not one. The practical threshold is this: even if you cannot yet measure, document what you intend to measure — that single act of clarity puts most KOBIs ahead of where they currently stand. When we return to the agency waiting for a brief six weeks before the season opens, the only missing item was a single page: target channel, content type, approving person, publishing frequency and one success criterion. That is not a grand strategy — but it is enough to put an entire three-month season on track.A digital strategy starts as a bright idea and, far too often, stays one. What makes it actionable is the connection between the first layer — brand identity — and the second layer — weekly operational flow. Building that connection does not require a lengthy document. It requires a consistent approval culture, a clear brief format and at least one agreed measurement criterion. The Antalya general manager carried 47 pages in his bag, but the one question he needed to ask the agency was simpler: ‘What are we starting with on Monday morning?’ Without a clear answer to that question, the strategy document can be as long as it likes and it will not matter.

This article was originally published in Turkish by Gökhan MERCANOĞLU on March 12, 2015. The English edition has been reviewed and edited by the author.


supplier performance creates lasting value only when user behavior, executive ownership, and data quality are handled together. Technology does not create transformation by itself; it only makes the need for transformation more visible. Success is less about the system working and more about the organization learning to work with it.


Gökhan Mercanoğlu
MRP, Üretim ve Tedarik Zinciri